Vertrauenswürdigkeit der Parteien
Evidenzbasierte Bewertung der Konsistenz, Ehrlichkeit, Kompetenz und Transparenz jeder Partei. Jede Note ist durch dokumentierte Belege gestützt. Dieses Werkzeug hilft Wählern, informierte Entscheidungen zu treffen — es empfiehlt nicht, wen man wählen soll.
Fidesz-KDNP
2010-2026 (Government) DD Versprechen halten
Anti-corruption pledge spectacularly broken: EU most corrupt 3 consecutive years. Utility cuts delivered but unsustainable. Family spending massive but fertility at record low 1.30. Healthcare spending gap widened. Press freedom rank fell 23rd to 68th.
F Ehrlichkeit
State media monopoly spreads government narratives unchallenged. Independent media destroyed (Index, Origo captured). "Stop Brussels" campaigns based on false premises. Soros conspiracy narrative contradicts facts.
F Integrität
Mészáros oligarch enrichment (€1.2B EU-funded contracts, 83% EU money). Tiborcz/Elios (56% overpriced, OLAF €40M repayment). Orbán family wealth explosion. No domestic prosecutions despite EU findings.
C Kompetenz
GDP growth above EU average (2014-2019). Low unemployment. But: highest inflation in EU (2022-23). Brain drain (600K+ emigrated). Healthcare system collapse. Education spending lowest in EU.
F Rechenschaftspflicht
Pegasus spying on journalists/opposition. KESMA media capture (~500 outlets). Constitutional Court packed. Electoral system redrawn. EU Art. 7 proceedings. €20B EU funds withheld for rule-of-law violations.
F Fairness gegenüber Gegnern
Opposition described as "foreign agents," "Soros network," "traitors." Government-controlled media runs campaigns against opposition candidates. Pegasus surveillance of journalists covering opposition.
Mi Hazánk
2022-2026 DNA Versprechen halten
Parliamentary party since 2022 (6 seats). Opposition — limited delivery expectations. Promotes anti-immigration, anti-LGBT, pro-Russia positions.
D Ehrlichkeit
Promotes anti-vaccination conspiracy theories. Climate denial. Anti-Roma rhetoric. Multiple statements contradicted by scientific consensus and official statistics.
NA Integrität
Small party, limited financial transparency data. No major corruption scandals documented. Leader Toroczkai is former Jobbik member.
D Kompetenz
Flagship proposals legally impossible (death penalty violates ECHR Protocol 13, Transcarpathia claim violates UN Charter). Anti-vaccination campaign contradicted EMA/FDA data, contributed to vaccine hesitancy. Dawn Program economic proposals vague with no fiscal modeling.
D Rechenschaftspflicht
Promotes illiberal positions (anti-LGBT rights, anti-immigration). Paramilitary-adjacent supporters. But: participates in parliamentary democracy, accepts electoral results.
D Fairness gegenüber Gegnern
Labels opponents as "globalists," "gender-ideologues." Uses conspiratorial framing. Anti-Soros rhetoric similar to Fidesz but more extreme.
Opposition coalition (HU)
2022 election NANA Versprechen halten
Never governed together. United opposition lost 2022 election decisively (34.4% vs 54.1%).
Tisza
2024-2026 BNA Versprechen halten
Founded 2024, no governance record. Led by Péter Magyar (former Fidesz insider turned critic). Rapidly gained support reaching 30%+ in polls by 2025.
B Ehrlichkeit
Magyar leverages insider knowledge to expose Fidesz corruption. Claims generally backed by documents and recordings. Some rhetorical exaggeration typical of opposition.
NA Integrität
Too new to assess. Magyar himself faced questions about past Fidesz connections and marriage to former Justice Minister Varga. No corruption charges.
NA Kompetenz
Founded 2024, governed from May 2026. EP delegation active but sanctioned by EPP. Policy programme published late (Feb 2026, 240 pages). One-man-show criticism: ~30 formal members, centralized leadership. Too early to assess governance outcomes.
B Rechenschaftspflicht
Party structure emerging. Magyar dominant figure but building organizational capacity. Participated in EP elections (7 MEPs elected June 2024). Democratic internal structure developing.
B Fairness gegenüber Gegnern
Criticism of Fidesz generally fact-based (corruption evidence, insider knowledge). Some personal attacks on Orbán but within political norms. No documented false claims about other opposition parties.
Vergleichstabelle
| Dimension | Fidesz-KDNP | Mi Hazánk | Opposition coalition (HU) | Tisza |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Versprechen halten | D | NA | NA | NA |
| Ehrlichkeit | F | D | NA | B |
| Integrität | F | NA | NA | NA |
| Kompetenz | C | D | NA | NA |
| Rechenschaftspflicht | F | D | NA | B |
| Fairness gegenüber Gegnern | F | D | NA | B |
| Gesamt | D | D | NA | B |
Methodik
Was wir messen
- Versprechen: Haben sie getan, was sie gesagt haben?
- Ehrlichkeit: Haben sie die Wahrheit gesagt?
- Integrität: Sind sie frei von Korruption?
- Kompetenz: Haben ihre Maßnahmen funktioniert?
- Rechenschaft: Akzeptieren sie Kontrolle?
Was wir nicht tun
- Wir sagen nicht, wen Sie wählen sollen
- Wir bewerten keine ideologischen Positionen
- Wir bestrafen keine Koalitionskompromisse (außer bei Leugnung)
- Wir verwenden keine Medienberichterstattung als Beweis
- Jede Note braucht 3+ unabhängige Quellen
Notenskala
- A Stark: konsistent, kleine Ausnahmen
- B Ausreichend: im Allgemeinen konsistent
- C Bedenklich: mehrere Widersprüche
- D Mangelhaft: systematisches Muster
- F Ungenügend: grundlegende Probleme